Dave Portnoy, the charismatic and controversial founder of Barstool Sports, has become an internet sensation for his outspoken personality and ability to connect with audiences. Over the years, Portnoy has evolved from a sports blogger to an entrepreneur and cultural phenomenon. One of his most popular projects, Barstool Pizza Review, has garnered millions of fans worldwide. The concept is simple: Portnoy, also known as “El Presidente,” reviews one pizza joint at a time, offering his famously blunt and entertaining one-bite analysis. Recently, Portnoy visited Frankie’s Pizza in Nashville, TN, where he awarded the establishment a solid 7.8 rating—a score that highlights Nashville’s growing reputation as a foodie destination.
Frankie’s Pizza is located at 925 Cherokee Ave, Nashville, TN 37207. You can reach them at (615) 964-7626. The store is open Monday through Sunday from 12 PM to 9 PM, with extended hours until 10 PM on Friday and Saturday.
The Man Behind the Brand
Dave Portnoy started Barstool Sports in 2003 as a small, Boston-based sports and pop culture blog. What began as a newspaper distributed to commuters quickly transitioned online, where it grew exponentially. Portnoy’s unfiltered humor and raw, sometimes controversial takes resonated with a predominantly male audience seeking entertainment beyond traditional sports reporting.
Over the years, Barstool Sports expanded to include a wide array of content, from podcasts and video series to merchandise and charity initiatives. In 2017, Penn Entertainment acquired a significant stake in the company, valuing Barstool Sports at over $450 million. Despite the growth, Portnoy has maintained a hands-on approach, especially with Barstool Pizza Review.
The Birth of Barstool Pizza Review
Barstool Pizza Review started as a casual idea. In 2017, while living in New York City, Portnoy decided to review every pizza spot in Manhattan. His goal was ambitious: try one slice at every pizzeria and provide a score between 0 and 10. Known for his mantra, “One bite, everyone knows the rules,” Portnoy would often take more than one bite before delivering his verdict.
The reviews quickly gained traction, blending comedy, honest critiques, and occasional celebrity guest appearances. Portnoy’s engaging personality and straightforward scoring system have made him a trusted voice in the pizza community. Whether he’s praising a perfectly crisp crust or calling out a soggy slice, his reviews have the power to make—or break—a pizzeria’s reputation.
A Slice of Nashville: Frankie’s Pizza
Portnoy’s pizza reviews have taken him across the country, and Nashville recently became the latest stop on his culinary map. Among the many options in Music City, Portnoy selected Frankie’s Pizza, a local favorite known for its classic approach to pizza-making.
In his review, Portnoy praised Frankie’s for its consistency and flavor, noting the balance of a crunchy crust, flavorful sauce, and quality cheese. The 7.8 rating is a testament to the high standards he applies to his reviews—it’s a score that puts Frankie’s in the “very good” category and makes it a must-visit for locals and tourists alike.
For Frankie’s, the review brought more than just a flattering score; it sparked a wave of attention. Food enthusiasts and Portnoy fans flooded social media with posts about the pizzeria, making it a trending spot in Nashville. Frankie’s owner expressed gratitude for the exposure, emphasizing the passion and effort their team puts into every pie.
Why Pizza Reviews Matter
While Barstool Pizza Review may seem like lighthearted entertainment, it has a significant cultural impact. Portnoy’s reviews have introduced audiences to hidden gems and family-owned establishments that might otherwise be overlooked. For small pizzerias, a good review can lead to increased foot traffic, social media buzz, and loyal customers.
Beyond the pizza itself, Portnoy’s reviews are a celebration of community and tradition. Each review offers a glimpse into the story behind the restaurant, from its origins to the people who make the pizza. It’s this human element, combined with Portnoy’s humor, that keeps viewers coming back for more.
Nashville: A Food Lover’s Paradise
Nashville has long been known for its vibrant music scene, but in recent years, it’s become a culinary destination as well. While hot chicken is the city’s most iconic dish, pizza has been quietly carving out its own niche. Frankie’s Pizza is a shining example of this trend, offering a mix of quality ingredients, attention to detail, and a welcoming atmosphere.
Portnoy’s visit to Frankie’s highlights another reason to explore Nashville. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, the city offers a diverse array of dining options that cater to every taste. Frankie’s now holds a special place on the map for anyone following Portnoy’s pizza adventures, adding to Nashville’s appeal as a must-visit destination.
The Barstool Effect
Portnoy’s influence extends far beyond the pizza world. His reviews have created what some call “The Barstool Effect,” where a single positive review can elevate a business overnight. Restaurants that score well often see lines out the door, increased online orders, and a surge in their social media presence.
Frankie’s Pizza is no exception. Following the 7.8 rating, the pizzeria experienced a noticeable uptick in customers eager to try the pizza that earned Portnoy’s approval. This phenomenon underscores the power of digital media and the role influencers like Portnoy play in shaping consumer choices.
Why Frankie’s Stands Out
Frankie’s Pizza embodies the qualities that make a pizzeria memorable. From its carefully crafted recipes to its friendly staff, every aspect of the experience is designed to leave a lasting impression. The high-quality ingredients, perfectly baked crust, and inviting atmosphere make Frankie’s a standout in Nashville’s competitive food scene.
Portnoy’s review highlighted these strengths, but the real magic of Frankie’s lies in its ability to make customers feel at home. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing a pie to go, Frankie’s delivers an authentic pizza experience that’s hard to beat.
Plan Your Visit
If you’re in Nashville, a trip to Frankie’s Pizza is a must. The 7.8 rating from Dave Portnoy isn’t just a number—it’s a stamp of approval from one of the internet’s most discerning pizza critics. While you’re there, take time to explore the rest of what Nashville has to offer, from live music and historic landmarks to a thriving food scene that’s constantly evolving.
Frankie’s Pizza is located at 925 Cherokee Ave, Nashville, TN 37207. For more information, call (615) 964-7626. The store is open Monday through Sunday from 12 PM to 9 PM, with extended hours until 10 PM on Friday and Saturday.
Dave Portnoy’s journey from sports blogger to pizza connoisseur is a testament to his entrepreneurial spirit and ability to connect with audiences. Barstool Pizza Review has become more than just a series of videos; it’s a celebration of food, community, and the stories that bring us together.
Frankie’s Pizza in Nashville is the latest pizzeria to earn Portnoy’s seal of approval, with a solid 7.8 rating that speaks to its quality and consistency. For locals and visitors alike, Frankie’s offers a chance to experience some of the best pizza in town—just one more reason to visit Music City. So, the next time you’re in Nashville, grab a slice, take a bite, and discover why this city is quickly becoming a pizza lover’s paradise. checkout the full review at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tjs7CvFSa9A&t=195s
